User Experiences Of The Cochrane Library

December 2017

Informatics

Country of origin: Europe

Evidence-based decision making relies on easy access to trustworthy research results. The Cochrane Library is a key source of evidence about the effect of interventions and aims to "promote the accessibility of systematic reviews to anyone wanting to make a decision about health care". Recent research explored how health professionals found, used and experienced The Library, looking at facets of user experience including findability, usability, usefulness, credibility, desirability and value.

Researchers carried out 32 one-hour usability tests on participants from Norway and the UK. Participants both browsed freely and attempted to perform individually tailored tasks while "thinking aloud". Sessions were recorded and viewed in real time by researchers. Transcriptions and videos were reviewed by one researcher and one designer. Findings reported reflect issues receiving a high degree of saturation and that are judged to be critical to the user experience of evidence-based web sites, based on principles for usability heuristics, web guidelines and evidence-based practice.

Participants had much difficulty locating both the site and its contents. Non-native English speakers were at an extra disadvantage when retrieving relevant documents despite high levels of English-language skills. Many participants displayed feelings of ineptitude, alienation and frustration. Some made serious mistakes in correctly distinguishing between different information types, for instance reviews, review protocols, and individual studies. Although most expressed a high regard for the site's credibility, some later displayed a mistrust of the independence of the information. Others were overconfident, thinking everything on The Cochrane Library site shared the same level of quality approval.

The article concludes that paradoxically, The Cochrane Library, established to support easy access to research evidence, has its own problems of accessibility. Health professionals' experiences of this and other evidence-based online resources can be improved by applying existing principles for web usability, prioritising the development of simple search functionality, emitting "researcher" jargon, consistent marking of site ownership, and clear signposting of different document types and different content quality.

The article, published in BMC Medical Informatics and Decision Making, is available online.

Resources

The Lancet March 2019 The Lancet

Available for both iPad & iPhone, the new and improved The Lancet app is free to download and offers...
MedCalX March 2019 MedCalX is a tool that enables medical professionals to easily use complicated medical formulas, scores and classifications.
Read by QxMD Personalized Medical Journal February 2019 Read is an app for both iOS and Android that centralizes all your medical literature and journals. Using a magazine format,...
MDCalc the best online medical calculator February 2019 MDCalc began life as an EM residentís WordPress site in 2005 and today is a highly-rated resource for practicing physicians...
Safety Features Of GP Computer Systems January 2019 A survey and study on the safety features required in GP computer systems, commissioned by the NPSA and published by the...
The CDC Clear Communication Index November 2018 The CDC Clear Communication Index (Index) is a research-based tool to help you develop and assess public communication...
PRIMIS + November 2018 The importance of data security and confidentiality is one of the issues that PRIMIS (Primary Care Information Services) is...
Journal of Medical Internet Research October 2018 The "Journal of Medical Internet Research" (JMIR; ISSN 1438-8871, Medline-abbreviation: J Med Internet Res), founded in...
Informatics, biometrics and epidemiology online July 2018 The scientific journal of the German Society for Medical Informatics, Biometrics and Epidemiology (Deutsche Gesellschaft...
Read by QxMD March 2018 There are a few ways to browse journal content. The landing screen is Featured Papers, which presents citations from your...
Search by Keyword